I Scream Gelato Columbus, Ohio

Get a Scoop of the Best Gelato in Columbus, OH

Ohio is a place that is known for its art and music scene, the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, and homemade buckeyes enjoyed with friends, family, and loved ones. Columbus, OH, has consistently been recognized for their thriving and diverse communities, but that is not all they are known for anymore – delicious authentic Italian Gelato is available on Polaris Fashion Mall Food Hall. This sweet frozen treat will more than pack a punch for your taste buds. I Scream Gelato is the newest scoop in town, but its flavors have been carefully crafted and deemed delicious before arriving in Ohio.

creamery near by columbus
what's better than ice cream?

Making things delicious is in their nature, and it all began in a town called Breckenridge in Colorado in 2018. Inspired by the flavors, textures, and quality of dessert in Milano, Italy, authentic Gelato’s density and creaminess always reigned supreme; soft serve, frozen custard, and ice cream just didn’t quite cut it. With experimentation and innovation in the mind of the creators, crafting the best Gelato and an even more exciting experience was the goal.

creamery in denver colorado

Upon opening its first location in 2018, I Scream Gelato heard its customers screaming for more and expanded their reach to Frisco, Denver & Miami, Florida. With gelato global domination in mind – I Scream found it necessary to bring this flavorful gift to Ohio and the rest of the world. They prioritize maintaining a world-class, high-quality dining experience, extraordinary desserts with a modern twist, and continued expansion with flavors, food, and more. I Scream Gelato in Columbus, OH, brings customers a little scoop of Italy to their doorstep!

This Isn't Frozen Custard or An Ice Cream Sandwich

I scream gelato columbus

While you may wonder if your current favorite ice cream shop carries Gelato – you would be sadly mistaken. While they may have delicious ice cream, they will never be able to encapsulate or serve the genuine goodness that is authentic Italian Gelato. People often wonder – what exactly is the difference between an ice cream shop and a gelato eatery? Is Gelato better for you health-wise? Is Gelato just a fancy name for ice cream, soft serve, frozen custard, or yogurt?

While the residents of Columbus, OH, may be used to generic ice cream sandwiches, traditional frozen custard, and all the typical flavors – Gelato brings something new to the dessert table…

  • Ice cream and frozen custard are created using a high quantity of cream and egg yolks, versus Gelato – which doesn’t typically call for egg yolks but uses more milk.
  • Gelato is churned slowly to ensure quality, reduce the air content and maintain the flavor.
  • Gelato has a much lower percentage of butterfat, about 4-9%, allowing customers a well-rounded tasting experience. Ice cream can use up to 14%, coating your tongue and dulling the flavor.
  • Gelato can be stored at a much lower temperature, at around 10-20 degrees, preserving your tasting experience and texture. Ice cream is almost always frozen, again pushing down the flavor.

Better Than Other Ice Cream Shops

I Scream Gelato is not your average ice cream shop; we collaborate on the perfect texture, flavors, milk, cream, and rich, sugary goodness to ensure clients have an explosion in their mouths. Every cup, cone, waffle, pancake, or how you choose to enjoy your Italian Gelato is made fresh to order and always delicious, not to mention you can also select all the toppings your heart desires!

Our gelato shop is in a prime location, Polaris Mall Food Court in Columbus, OH – when customers are searching for something cool and flavorful to eat, I Scream have you back every single time. Check out our reviews – we are the real deal, and whether you are more of a traditional, vanilla and chocolate person, or you prefer vegan mango or pineapple – you can always find a cup of something you can enjoy, even freshly brewed coffee and espresso.

Treat Your Taste Buds to International Flavors

Gelato is actually the Italian word for ice cream; after all, to have a genuine experience while enjoying your ice cream snack at Polaris Fashion Mall Food Hall, you need to have something authentic. To keep true to Gelato’s Italian roots, I Scream Gelato sources the finest ingredients to their location directly from Italy! It is our gift to our customers – anything less than excellent isn’t quite good enough.

Crafting Gelato is an art form; you can’t develop a decadent chocolate flavor or the sweetest stracciatella without some profound experience and passion for your position. I Scream Gelato is fully dedicated to creating an adventure from your gelato snack. We bring a little bit of the outside world directly to Polaris Fashion Mall in Columbus, OH, and you won’t get enough of it!

italian ice cream near me
  • Panacotta – is a traditional Italian delicacy, and I Scream has brought it to its customers correctly. It is dense, rich, velvety, and highly decadent – bringing a summer of Italy to Columbus, OH.
  • Creme Brulee – This isn’t your average creme brulee – the sweet treat is known for its deep flavor and light feeling, and in gelato form, you can experience French traditions and flavors without having to fly overseas!
  • Dulce De Leche – this is a prevalent flavor south of the equator, and while it has caught in America everywhere, have you ever experienced it as a scoop of Gelato? Italy meets the South American tradition to make the sweetest, most terrific, and most caramel-iest scoop of deliciousness!
  • Pistachio is a more traditional flavor favorite for ice cream; without resorting to the standard vanilla or chocolate, why not try something new? Pistachio gelato has the best of all worlds. It has nuttiness, creaminess, and excellent candied flavors, all in one cup or fresh bubble cone.

All Your Favorite Flavors

You can find just about any flavor favorite at I Scream Gelato’s Columbus location, from chocolate to strawberry and all the usual suspects to Oreo, Ferraro Roche, and Donut – something that will take you for a stroll on the wilder side of life. There is something for everyone; you can try a new flavor every time you visit! After all, this wasn’t created to be just another gelato shop – I Scream aims to provide the most excellent scoops in the nation and will continue expanding location options so everyone in America can enjoy this frozen treat!

best ice cream denver

Scoop Up Something You Know

People love the feeling of comfort, and foods are a massive part of bringing people those feelings of security. From the tradition of eating to the dining set, smells, tastes, and textures – what we eat is engrained into our DNA and is a part of who we are. I Scream Gelato provides all the classic flavor options you have long known and surely love -, but they offer a modern twist and new ways of serving that spin how you are used to enjoying frozen treats.

Traditional Gelato Flavors At I Scream Gelato Columbus

  • Chocolate – there is nothing quite like the delicious taste of chocolate, and when you can enjoy it in the cool form of Gelato on a hot Spring or summer day, it really hits the spot. (Try it with extra chocolate toppings on top if you are a true chocolate lover!)
  • Hazelnut is its flavor; when it stands alone, it is incredibly bold, rich, and tasty. I Scream recommends this with nothing other than more chocolate toppings and even a bit of Biscoff cookies to add a bit of crunch to your scoops.
  • Caramel – this is a classic, and while it can be enjoyed any time of the day, it is especially lovely to add nodes of vanilla or additional flavors into your cup to get full I Scream experience!
  • Vanilla – the most traditional of flavors for any cool treat is vanilla. If you are not significant, bold flavors, I Scream’s vanilla gelato has depth and can be enjoyed over a stack of pancakes for a full place of sugary goodness!
  • Coffee – get all the beautiful aroma and flavors of a freshly brewed cup of Joe; why not have a scoop of Gelato in the morning instead?

Try Out a New Flavor

If you have your go-to ice cream flavors parsed out, you can surely give something new a go! Everything is offered with any topping, syrup, or goodie of your choice, the portion size you prefer. It can be served on a platter of pancakes, fresh Belgian waffles, inside a bubble cone, as a cookie sandwich, or between a piece of Brioche! Our reviews speak for themselves – this is far from your typical ice cream shop.

ice cream waffle

Other Shops Just Can't Compete With These Funky Flavors

  • Vanilla Whiskey Cream – Vanilla lovers? Enjoy your favorite cool treat with a side of extra creaminess, smokiness, and a hint of whiskey on the side!
  • Banana Chocolate – Not interested in just doing plain old chocolate gelato? Try this out instead, nothing else pairs better with chocolate, and you can get a drizzle of peanut butter on top of your scoop to have a party in your mouth.
  • Mocha Cookie Crumble – Go a step further than coffee gelato and try out an excellent twist on mocha, with a pinch of cookie crumbles to add texture and crunch to your scoop!
  • Biscoff – A lover of the traditional Biscoff cookies? I Scream has made it into Gelato, and it couldn’t be perfect!
  • Smores – Bring the campfire to your mouth and indulge in graham crackers, chocolate, and marshmallows in one bite. These are just a few gelato options; check our menu for more!

Get Your Favorite Frozen Treat Delivered

Don’t have time to make the trip, or are you just having a lazy day to reboot at home? No problem – I Scream Gelato can deliver fresh Italian Gelato straight to your door. Because of its typically storing temperature, unlike ice cream, you don’t have to worry about it melting by the time it gets to you! Whether you want it on a waffle sprinkled with gummy bears and Sour Patch Kids, or you are just hoping for a couple of scoops and an Americano on the sideI Scream makes it easy and always wants to ensure customers receive everything their heart desires!

Gelato Pick-Up Made Easy

I Scream Gelato understands that life is busy, but even when your schedule is packed full, there is always a minute for the great indulgences available. In Columbus, OH, there is now the sweetest of treats in your neighborhood! Too busy to sit down and have the full I Scream experience? No worries – hop onto the website and place a quick order for pick-up! Each order is tailored to suit your needs, and if you aren’t sure what to go for? Ask one of our team members; we would be happy to make a recommendation for you!

Cater Traditional Flavors or Something More Unique

Are you interested in a project a little bit bigger than just a group of hungry teenagers at home for the weekend? I Scream Gelato has several catering options available to suit your gelato needs! Our gelato catering is as creamy as ever, always fresh, and guaranteed to be delicious. Whether you are just throwing a summer pool party or have been planning a baby shower for months, Gelato is the perfect way to make memories that will last for the rest of your life, and I Scream would be privileged to be a part of it.

Delicious Frequently Asked Questions

Gelato is and always will be unlike what you will find at Graeter’s ice cream because it isn’t ice cream! Gelato has a custard-style base and uses milk, cream, and sugar but never egg yolks. It is known for its density as it is churned slowly so that less air remains in the mixture and can be stored at a much higher temperature – producing bold flavors and a more well-rounded experience.

Italian ice is made with flavoring and ice, so it is certainly nothing like Gelato. Frozen yogurt has a yogurt base versus custard, which Gelato often uses and cannot pack the same flavors as Gelato.

It is innate to worry about your health, whether considering allergies, vegan or vegetarian preferences, or hoping to cut down on sugars and fats. While most reviews state that Gelato contains less milk and butter fat. The milk over cream in Gelato makes it denser and enhances its intensity flavorwise, but you won’t end up with the same fat content in ice cream!

I Scream Gelato does all things decadent, and Affogato is no exception – serving Whiskey Barrell coffee straight from Denver, CO, to create the traditional Italian beverage of choice. An affogato is an espresso served over a scoop of vanilla gelato, but that isn’t all I Scream offers – you can order your morning coffee, latte, cappuccino, blonde, or even hot chocolate!

Birthday Parties, Weddings, or Special Occasions - Any is a Good Excuse for the Best Gelato In Town

  • Weddings – Saying I Do? Say yes to Gelato for your guests; it is a great way to indulge in something sugary without having all the messiness of cutting the cake!
  • Birthday Parties – What better way to celebrate with loved ones for another trip around the sun than with fresh, authentic Gelato? There are flavors available for everyone in attendance!
  • Baby Showers/Gender Reveal – Wanting to reveal the gender of your new bundle of joy or hoping to celebrate your child’s arrival to this world? Gelato can provide pink and blue galore – and satisfy a pregnancy craving or two.
  • Graduations – High School and College grads have done all the work, so allow I Scream to take it from here! Scrap ice cream, we can bring out a cart of gelato fit for anyone’s preferences.
  • Office Parties/Corporate Events – Want to collaborate on something tasty? I Scream Gelato does office parties, retirement celebrations, regular meetings, or whatever you may need, even if you are hoping for a treat every week!
  • Or whatever you need Gelato for!

Stop By I Scream Gelato in Columbus, OH, for Delicious Desserts, Guaranteed

I Scream Gelato Columbus is wholly committed to crafting the best Gelato in the country – sourcing authentic ingredients, using the finest tools for churning straight from Italy, and creating an inclusive, fun, and vibrant environment for clients from all walks of life. If there is one thing most people can unite over, it is sweets – something we all know and love. Gelato reigns supreme regarding frozen treats, and I Scream’s recipes will leave you screaming and shouting for more. We are serving up the future in the form of authentic Italian Gelato, and we intend to continue evolving to encapsulate further the beauty and fragility within human connection over a fresh scoop of Gelato. Come get your scoop today!

ice cream in colombus

Our Customers Are Always Screaming For More - Columbus Client Reviews

Kennedy K.
Kennedy K.
@Colombus
Read More
Homemade Gelato Milkshakes in Polaris Mall Columbus, OH! We used to visit Coppa Gelato, but we were hooked once we found I Scream! One scoop of their Forrer Roche gelato was covered with chocolate syrup, and I thought I was in heaven. Graeter's Ice Cream has nothing on I Sceam Gelato, and I couldn't be more excited they have a location in Columbus, OH.
Sam R.
Sam R.
@Colombus
Read More
Delicious Ice Cream Couldn't Stand a Chance! f you think you have experienced great ice cream, think again. At I Scream Gelato, the cookies and cream flavor is something you can't imagine in your wildest dreams. Ice cream could never be compared to the flavorful, rich, and dense options they have available to create!
Ethan M.
Ethan M.
@Colombus
Read More
Gorgeous Gelato Eats in Grove City! I wish I could say reviews scratch the surface of the great big world of yum I Scream Gelato has provided with its drinks, desserts, and all the sweet treats - but it just cannot. Indulging at I Scream is an authentic experience - from making gelato sandwiches with two pancakes or indulging in Affogato after a day at work. Their bakery and churning skills are unmatched!
Kelsey C
Kelsey C
@Colombus
Read More
The Greatest Dessert in Columbus, OH! We used to visit Coppa Gelato, but we were hooked once we found I Scream! One scoop of their Forrer Roche gelato was covered with chocolate syrup, and I thought I was in heaven. Graeter's Ice Cream has nothing on I Sceam Gelato, and I couldn't be more excited they have a location in Columbus, OH.
Carrie S.
Carrie S.
@Colombus
Read More
Sweet, Fresh Frozen Treats in Polaris Mall, Columbus, OH! Grab a cup of traditional chocolate gelato or try out a delicious Swiss roll over Belgian waffles - I Scream Gelato in Columbus, OH, is absolutely amazing! Their flavor selection makes it difficult to choose because there is never a doubt each one will be wonderful, and the toppings are to die for!
Tory V.
Tory V.
@Colombus
Read More
You Can't Beat the Flavor at This Location! Ice cream is a thing of the past, Italian ice is just okay, frozen yogurt is just meh, and soft serve, and Coppa Gelato is something I will never think about again - all because of I Scream Gelato in Columbus, OH. Their milkshakes, espresso, and homemade bubble waffle cones will never do you wrong plus - you can create your treats and explore the best Gelato in Ohio!
Derek J.
Derek J.
@Colombus
Read More
Yummy - This Place is a Gift to Upper Arlington! I have always been a fan of Coppa Gelato and Grater's Ice Cream in Columbus, OH, which is okay, but - you cannot beat authentic Gelato with a unique experience! I Scream Gelato has a great location, delicious chocolate gelato, great reviews, customer service, and a good atmosphere. If you haven't tried it, you must get a scoop immediately! .
Kennedy K.
Kennedy K.
@Colombus
Read More
Fantastic Gelato & Dessert Restaurant in Ohio! I am vegan, and I have found it challenging to find good food and drinks in Polaris Mall, Columbus, OH, but luckily I Scream Gelato has brought a gift to my life! My favorite flavor is the vegan Mango gelato - you can sit and enjoy your time without questioning the ingredients' quality and the company's integrity.
Kennedy K.
Kennedy K.
@Colombus
Read More
Unique Flavors, Tasty Toppings & Amazing Service! I live off of High St in Columbus, OH, and I prefer convenience over almost everything, so I used to frequent Coppa Gelato, Graeter's Ice Cream, and other local ice cream & frozen yogurt vendors. There is nothing like Italian ice and a sweet frozen treat on a sweltering day in Ohio. I Scream Gelato treats its customers like gold, and they never sacrifice taste or flavor. .
Sky R.
Sky R.
@Colombus
Read More
Amazing Authentic Gelato - The Best I Have Ever Tasted Living in Columbus, OH, I enjoy checking out reviews before I visit any food or restaurant location. Reviews give me an idea of other customers' experiences at any particular eatery, which is why I enjoy leaving reviews myself. I Scream Gelato does Gelato correctly - offering rich, bold, fresh flavors, tasty topping options, and endless coffee. If you haven't already visited their newest location in Ohio, this is your sign!
Previous
Next

I Scream Contact Information

Follow Us on Social Media

Colombus, OH

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go
Doordash

Gulf Shores, AL

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go
Doordash

Miami, FL (S Beach)

Choose Your Carrier

GetSauce

Denver, CO (Lowry)

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go
Doordash
ice cream delivery
UberEats
ice cream near me
GrubHub

Frisco, CO

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go
Doordash

Breckenridge, CO

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go
Doordash
ice cream store
Warrior Express