Gelato vs. Sorbet: What’s the Difference and What Do Miami Locals Prefer?

The US industry-leading gelato manufacturer's blog

What Do Miami Locals Prefer?

Hello, sweet-toothed readers! Today, we’re diving into a delicious debate that has been stirring up the dessert world: Gelato vs. Sorbet. What’s the difference, and which one do Miami locals prefer? Let’s find out!

Gelato’s denser texture makes for a deeper, richer flavor sensation than ice cream

The Scoop on Gelato

First, let’s talk about gelato. Originating from Italy, gelato has become a beloved treat worldwide, and Miami is no exception. Gelato is made with milk, sugar, and flavorings like fruit and nuts. But what sets it apart from regular ice cream is its dense, smooth texture and intense flavor. This is achieved by churning the mixture at a slower speed, which incorporates less air and results in a richer treat.

In our sunny city of Miami, gelato is a favorite way to cool down. It’s not uncommon to see locals and tourists alike strolling down the beach, gelato in hand, enjoying the refreshing ocean breeze.

Sorbet offers a water-based alternative to gelato and is ideal for dessert lovers with dietary restrictions

The Skinny on Sorbet

On the other hand, we have sorbet, a fruity and dairy-free alternative to gelato. Sorbet is made from fruit puree, water, and sugar, resulting in a light, icy texture. It’s the perfect choice for those who are lactose intolerant or looking for a lower-fat option.

Sorbet is also a popular choice for cleansing the palate between courses during a meal. Its bright, clean flavors can reset your taste buds and prepare them for the next delicious dish.

gelato scoop
When comparing gelato and sorbet, each have their ups and downs

What People Also Ask

What is healthier, gelato or sorbet?

When it comes to health, both gelato and sorbet have their advantages. Gelato is typically lower in fat than traditional ice cream because it’s made with more milk than cream. However, it does contain dairy and is higher in sugar.

Sorbet, on the other hand, is dairy-free and can be a great choice for those with lactose intolerance. It’s also typically lower in calories than gelato. However, it’s worth noting that sorbet can sometimes contain more sugar than gelato to balance the tartness of the fruit.

So, in terms of health, it really depends on your dietary needs and preferences!

What is sorbet vs gelato vs sherbet?

Sorbet, gelato, and sherbet are all delicious frozen desserts, but they each have their unique characteristics. We’ve already covered sorbet and gelato, so let’s talk about sherbet.

Sherbet is a bit of a middle ground between sorbet and ice cream. It contains fruit, sugar, and water-like sorbet, but also includes a small amount of dairy for creaminess. However, the dairy content in sherbet is less than that in gelato or ice cream.

Which is healthier, sorbet or sherbet?

In terms of health, sorbet is typically lower in calories and fat because it doesn’t contain dairy. However, sherbet, with its small amount of dairy, can provide a bit of calcium. Both can contain a fair amount of sugar, so it’s best to enjoy them in moderation.

gelato scoop
People love gelato because of this dense texture, something you wont find in the fluffier ice cream or snowy sorbet

Why is gelato so much better?

Many people love gelato for its creamy, dense texture and intense flavor. The slow churning process and the higher proportion of milk to cream result in less air being incorporated, making gelato denser and more flavorful than traditional ice cream. Plus, gelato is served at a slightly warmer temperature, which allows the flavors to really shine.

Is gelato better for diabetics than ice cream?

Gelato can be a better choice than traditional ice cream for some people with diabetes because it’s often lower in fat. However, it’s important to remember that both gelato and ice cream contain sugar. If you have diabetes, it’s crucial to monitor your carbohydrate intake and consider the sugar content of these desserts. As always, moderation is key!

Remember, everyone’s dietary needs and preferences are different. Whether you’re team gelato, team sorbet, or team sherbet, the best choice is the one that brings you joy and fits into your balanced diet. Enjoy your frozen treats!

italian ice
Italian ice is the more crystallized version of sorbet. It more closely resembles a loosely packed snowball rather than the more dense sorbet counterpart

Is Italian ice just sorbet?

Italian ice and sorbet are similar in that they’re both made with fruit, sugar, and water. However, there’s a key difference in the way they’re made. Sorbet is churned, which gives it a smoother, more velvety texture. Italian ice, on the other hand, is typically made by freezing the mixture and stirring it occasionally, which results in a more granular, icy texture. So, while they’re similar, Italian ice and sorbet are not exactly the same.

Why is sorbet called dirty ice cream?

The term “dirty ice cream” is actually a colloquial term used in the Philippines to refer to locally-made ice cream sold by street vendors. It’s called “dirty” not because it’s unclean or unsafe to eat, but because it’s made and sold outside of commercial factories or shops.

Sorbet, gelato, and other types of ice cream are all different, and the term “dirty ice cream” is specific to the Philippines and doesn’t apply to sorbet in general. So, sorbet isn’t typically called “dirty ice cream” unless you’re in the Philippines and referring to a specific type of street food.

sorbet or gelato
We at I Scream Gelato boast a variety of gelatos and sorbets for everyone and every taste palate. Which dessert do you prefer?

Miami’s Verdict: Gelato or Sorbet?

Now, for the million-dollar question: What do Miami locals prefer? Well, based on our experience at I Scream Gelato, it’s safe to say that both gelato and sorbet have their loyal fans.

Gelato, with its creamy texture and rich flavors, is a hit among those who enjoy indulgent treats. On the other hand, sorbet, with its fruity freshness, is loved by those seeking a lighter, more refreshing option.

But why choose one when you can have both? At I Scream Gelato Miami, we offer a wide range of both gelato and sorbet flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for a decadent chocolate hazelnut gelato or a tangy mango sorbet, we’ve got you covered.

And the best part? You can enjoy our treats wherever you are! We offer catering services throughout Miami for parties and events, and if you’re in the mood for a cozy night in, you can order our gelato and sorbet to go or for delivery.

miami storefront
Come check us out at 211 Lincoln Rd down on Miami Beach. See for yourself what treats we have in store!

Join the Conversation

So, what’s your verdict, Miami? Are you team gelato or team sorbet? Or, like us, do you believe there’s a time and place for both? Share your thoughts in the comments below. We love hearing from our readers!

Remember, whether it’s gelato or sorbet, the most important thing is to enjoy every spoonful. After all, life is like gelato – it’s best enjoyed one scoop at a time!

Stay sweet, Miami!

Gulf Shores, AL

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go

Colombus, OH

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go

Miami, FL (S Beach)

Choose Your Carrier


Denver, CO (Lowry)

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go
ice cream delivery
ice cream near me

Frisco, CO

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go

Breckenridge, CO

Choose Your Carrier

ice cream to go
ice cream store
Warrior Express